Best Food Storage Containers for Leftovers: 6 Picks for Thanksgiving, From Freezer-to-Oven Glass to Send-Home Tubs

Thanksgiving leftovers have a clock on them. USDA says to get cooked food into the fridge within two hours, and to use refrigerated leftovers within about four days or freeze them. That makes the containers you own part of the plan: shallow ones that let food cool fast, lids that don’t leak gravy, something for the freezer, and a few you don’t mind sending home with guests. Here are six options matched to those jobs, with the listed specs that decide which one fits your kitchen.

By Avery Linden · Updated November 2026 · Research-based comparison, not a hands-on test

Three glass food storage containers filled with rice, vegetables and lentils
Illustrative photograph by Ella Olsson / Unsplash. It does not show the products below.
The short version

For reheating in the oven, look at glass with an oven rating on the glass itself, like the OXO Smart Seal set. For a big, everyday glass set, Pyrex Simply Store. For soup and gravy that has to travel, a latching, leakproof plastic set like Rubbermaid Brilliance. For guests, a cheap stack of TakeAlongs. For the freezer, Souper Cubes for portioned stock and gravy, or a Stasher bag for turkey frozen flat. Most homes need two of these, not all six.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We couldn’t confirm exact Amazon listing IDs for these products, so the buttons below are clearly labeled Amazon searches for each brand and model. Match the set size and piece count on the live listing before you order.

The six at a glance

PickBest forMaterialListed care notes
OXO Good Grips Smart Seal 12-piece glassFreezer to oven reheatsBorosilicate glass, locking lidsOven safe to 450°F (set listing); dishwasher, freezer, microwave
Pyrex Simply Store 18-pieceA big everyday glass setTempered glass, BPA-free plastic lidsLids microwave, top-rack and freezer safe; oven use not stated on the page
Rubbermaid Brilliance 10-pieceSoup and gravy that travelsTritan plastic, latching lidsMicrowave (vents), top-rack dishwasher, freezer
Rubbermaid TakeAlongs 4-cup, 6-packSending food home with guestsBPA-free plasticBase microwave safe; top-rack dishwasher; freezer
Souper Cubes 1-cup trayFreezing stock, gravy and sides in portionsFood-grade silicone, steel frameTray oven safe to 415°F; microwave; dishwasher
Stasher Half Gallon bagTurkey frozen flatPlatinum siliconeOven to 425°F, microwave, dishwasher, freezer
Best for freezer-to-oven reheats

OXO Good Grips Smart Seal 12-Piece Glass Container Set

Listed: 6 containers with lids: two 4 oz, two 1 cup, one 1.6 cup, one 3.5 cup · borosilicate glass · four locking tabs and a removable silicone seal · oven safe to 450°F; dishwasher, freezer and microwave safe · glass nests for storage · model 11230200 (Kohl’s listing)

The listing describes this set as made to go from freezer to oven, which is exactly what you want for a portion of stuffing or a scoop of sweet potatoes in mid-December. The locking tabs and removable silicone seal are the parts that keep gravy where it belongs, and the seal coming out means you can wash under it.

The pieces are on the small side. The largest is 3.5 cups, so this is a set for portions and side dishes, not for a whole pan of leftover stuffing.

Why consider it

Glass you can reheat in the oven, with lids built to seal. The smaller sizes suit single servings for lunches.

Who should skip it

Anyone who needs big containers, or who wants a lighter set to carry. The listing doesn’t separate glass and lid ratings, so take the lid off before the oven unless OXO’s care instructions say otherwise.

Search Amazon for the OXO Smart Seal 12-piece set ↗

Kohl’s listing with set contents and care notes

Best big everyday glass set

Pyrex Simply Store 18-Piece Glass Storage Set

Listed: 9 glass containers with 9 lids: one 7-cup round, one 6-cup rectangle, one 4-cup round, two 3-cup rectangles, two 2-cup rounds, two 1-cup rounds · tempered glass, BPA-free plastic lids · glass handles microwave and dishwasher use; lids microwave safe, top-rack dishwasher safe and freezer safe · model 1128223 (Pyrex)

This is the set many kitchens already have a piece or two of, and the size spread is what makes it useful in November. The 6-cup rectangle, listed at 7.5 by 6.5 by 2.25 inches, is a good shape for a layer of sliced turkey, and the 7-cup round holds a real amount of mashed potatoes or soup. Nine containers is enough to split a holiday’s worth of sides without stacking everything into one tub.

The lids are snap-on plastic, not latching. They’re fine for the fridge, but they aren’t the ones to trust with soup on a car seat.

Why consider it

A wide range of sizes in glass, from 1 cup to 7 cups, in one box.

Who should skip it

Anyone carrying liquids, and anyone expecting oven use: the Pyrex page doesn’t state oven use for this set, so check the care instructions in the box first. Glass is also heavy for a lunch bag.

Search Amazon for the Pyrex Simply Store 18-piece set ↗

Pyrex product page with sizes and dimensions

Best for soup and gravy that travels

Rubbermaid Brilliance Leak-Proof 10-Piece Set

Listed: 5 containers with lids in three sizes (two small, two medium, one large) · BPA-free Tritan plastic, described as shatter-resistant and stain- and odor-resistant · dual-latch lids described as 100% airtight and leakproof · vents under the latches for microwaving with the lid on and latches open · microwave, top-rack dishwasher and freezer safe (Walmart listing)

Brilliance is the set to reach for when the leftovers are liquid. The latches clamp the lid down on two sides, and the vents mean you can microwave a bowl of soup without peeling the lid off and getting splattered. Tritan is clear like glass, so you can see what’s inside the stack without opening every lid, but it weighs far less.

Rubbermaid’s own page for a smaller Brilliance set lists 1.3-cup and 3.2-cup pieces; check the exact sizes on the listing you buy, because the Walmart listing doesn’t spell out each container’s capacity clearly.

Why consider it

Latching, leakproof-rated lids, light enough to carry, and lids that fit more than one container size.

Who should skip it

Anyone who wants to reheat in the oven, or who prefers not to microwave food in plastic. Look at the glass picks above instead.

Search Amazon for Rubbermaid Brilliance 10-piece ↗

Walmart listing with features · Rubbermaid Brilliance product page

Best for sending food home with guests

Rubbermaid TakeAlongs 4-Cup Rectangle, Set of 6

Listed: six 4-cup (946 ml) containers with lids, 12 pieces · BPA-free plastic · base microwave safe · top-rack dishwasher safe · freezer safe · ridged lids for stacking (Walmart listing)

The polite way to clear a fridge after Thanksgiving is to send plates home with people. TakeAlongs are sold for exactly that kind of use: inexpensive enough that you won’t chase anyone to get them back. Six matching 4-cup containers is a useful size for a plate’s worth of turkey, stuffing and a slice of pie, and the lids stack so a pile of them doesn’t slide off the counter.

Why consider it

Low-cost, matching and freezer safe, so the guest who takes one home can freeze it too.

Who should skip it

Anyone looking for long-term everyday containers or a leakproof seal; the listing doesn’t claim one. The page only says the base is microwave safe, so take the lid off before reheating.

Search Amazon for Rubbermaid TakeAlongs 4-cup ↗

Walmart listing with capacity and care notes

Plates and glasses with leftover food on a table after a meal
The two-hour clock starts when the food comes off the heat, not when the meal ends. Photograph by Teo Zac / Unsplash.
Best for freezing stock, gravy and sides

Souper Cubes 1-Cup Freezer Tray

Listed: four 1-cup portions per tray · fill lines at ½ cup and 1 cup · food-grade silicone with an embedded steel frame · fitted lid that stacks · tray oven safe to 415°F (tray only); microwave safe; tray and lid dishwasher safe · 11.75 × 5.75 × 2.5 in (Souper Cubes)

Turkey stock from the carcass, leftover gravy and cranberry sauce all freeze well in measured blocks. You fill the tray, freeze it, pop out the cubes and move them to a labeled bag or container, then the tray is free for the next batch. A 1-cup block is a practical unit: one cup of gravy for a weeknight, or a few cups of stock for soup.

Souper Cubes says most foods take up to 24 hours to freeze in the tray, so plan for the tray to sit in the freezer for a day before you pop the cubes out.

Why consider it

Portioned freezing without guessing, and the steel frame keeps a full tray from flopping on the way to the freezer.

Who should skip it

Anyone with a small freezer and no flat shelf for an 11.75-inch tray, or anyone who only freezes a few things a year; zip bags laid flat work fine for that.

Search Amazon for Souper Cubes 1-cup tray ↗

Souper Cubes product page with specs

Best for turkey frozen flat

Stasher Half Gallon Reusable Silicone Bag

Listed: 64 fl oz (1,893 ml) · 8.5 × 10.25 × 1.5 in · food-grade platinum silicone · Pinch-Loc seal described as leak-free · dishwasher, microwave and oven safe to 425°F; freezer safe · avoid open flames, broilers and sharp objects (Stasher)

Sliced turkey frozen flat in a bag thaws faster and stacks like a book in the freezer. A reusable silicone bag does the same job as a gallon zip bag, but you wash it instead of throwing it away. Press the air out before sealing, lay it flat on a sheet pan until it’s frozen, then stand it up in a bin.

Why consider it

Reusable and listed as freezer, microwave and dishwasher safe, so one bag handles freezing, thawing and reheating.

Who should skip it

Anyone who finds bags harder to clean than boxes. Silicone needs a good scrub at the seal, and it costs far more up front than disposable bags.

Search Amazon for the Stasher Half Gallon bag ↗

Stasher product page with size and care notes

How to pack Thanksgiving leftovers so they last

The container matters less than how you use it. USDA’s guidance, in plain terms:

  • Two hours, or one if it’s hot. Refrigerate leftovers within 2 hours of cooking, or within 1 hour if the room is above 90°F. Hot food can go straight into the fridge.
  • Go shallow. Divide big amounts into shallow containers so they cool quickly. Carve the turkey off the bird and split it into smaller pieces rather than refrigerating the whole carcass.
  • Cover everything. Seal containers, or wrap food airtight, to keep bacteria out and moisture in.
  • Use or freeze within about four days. USDA’s general leftovers page says 3 to 4 days in the fridge; frozen leftovers stay safe indefinitely at 0°F, but quality drops over time, and 3 to 4 months is USDA’s guide for best quality.
  • Reheat to 165°F, checked with a food thermometer.
A clear glass jar of broth
Stock from the turkey carcass freezes well in measured portions. Photograph by Jonathan Pielmayer / Unsplash.
A simple labeling habit: write what it is and the date on a strip of masking tape before the lid goes on. On a busy weekend, “turkey, Thu” is the difference between eating it Sunday and wondering about it Tuesday. If you’d rather print labels, our label maker comparison covers three styles.

Glass or plastic?

Glass is heavier and can break, but it doesn’t hold stains or smells, and some glass is rated for the oven. Plastic like Tritan is light and shatter-resistant, which makes it better for carrying and for kids’ hands. A practical split for most homes: glass for what stays in the kitchen and gets reheated, latching plastic for anything that leaves the house or holds liquid.

Whatever you choose, follow each maker’s own temperature limits. Some sets rate the glass and lids differently, and some pages don’t mention the oven at all.

How we chose

This is a research-based comparison from listed specifications, not hands-on testing. We looked for containers from established brands sold at major US retailers, matched them to the jobs leftovers actually need (reheating, carrying liquids, sending home, freezing), and recorded only what the manufacturer or retailer pages state. Specs were checked on November 6, 2026, from the pages linked under each product. We didn’t include prices or ratings because they change often, especially around Black Friday. See our editorial policy.

Buying checklist
  • Do you reheat in the oven? Then check the oven rating for the glass, and for the lid separately.
  • Will anything travel? Choose latching lids with a leakproof claim for soup and gravy.
  • Measure your fridge shelf height and the freezer shelf you’ll use.
  • Count containers by job: a few large, several 2 to 4 cup, a couple small.
  • Check the piece count: “18 pieces” usually means 9 containers and 9 lids.
  • Decide where the lids will live before you buy; see our kitchen drawer guide.

Questions

How long are Thanksgiving leftovers good in the fridge?

USDA says to use refrigerated leftovers within about four days, or freeze them. Refrigerate within 2 hours of cooking.

Can I put warm leftovers straight in the fridge?

Yes. USDA says hot food can go directly into the refrigerator. Splitting it into shallow containers helps it cool faster.

Are glass containers oven safe?

Only if the maker says so. The OXO Smart Seal set’s listing gives 450°F; the Pyrex Simply Store page doesn’t state oven use. Plastic lids generally shouldn’t go in the oven unless the instructions say they can.

Getting the whole house guest-ready too? Our cleaning supply storage ideas help you find the glass cleaner before Wednesday night. Planning the fridge itself? Our Thanksgiving fridge countdown walks through clearing space a week out and where the leftovers go.

Sources: USDA FSIS, Leftovers and Food Safety · USDA FSIS, Food Safety: The Best Ingredient for Thanksgiving Leftovers. Product specs from the manufacturer and retailer pages linked above.

Best containers for Thanksgiving leftovers: oven-safe glass, gravy-proof lids and send-home tubs
Save these picks to your Pinterest board for Thanksgiving week.

Keep reading

More guides for your space

THE KINDRED JOURNAL

Latest from the journal