Quick answer: if your drawer is under about 10½ inches wide inside, look at a narrow tiered tray. If it is a full-width kitchen drawer, an expandable steel rack or a trimmable wood insert can fill it edge to edge. And if your jars come in five different sizes, a cut-to-length foam liner may beat any tray. The rest of this guide shows which listed dimensions decide that.

Renters, odd sizes, mixed jars: YouCopia SpiceLiner. Narrow drawer or half a drawer: iDesign Linus or LYNK Professional 10-inch tray. Wide drawer, big collection: LYNK Professional expandable tray. Built-in look, willing to cut: Rev-A-Shelf 4SDI-18 maple insert.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. One link below opens a product listing identified through a third-party page; the others are clearly labeled Amazon searches for the brand and model. Check the size and variant on the live listing before you order.
The five side by side
Sizes are as listed by the manufacturer or retailer in inches (width × depth × height). Where two sources disagree, both figures are shown. Jar height is not part of these numbers: an insert’s height plus a jar lying on it is what has to clear the drawer above.
| Product | Listed size | Material | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| YouCopia SpiceLiner | 10 ft roll, 2.5 in wide strips, cut to length | NBR foam | Renters, any drawer size, mixed jars |
| iDesign Linus In-Drawer Spice Rack | 8.5 × 16.6 × 1.5 (Container Store); 8.04 × 15.54 × 1.16 (Ace) | Plastic | Narrow drawers, pairing two side by side |
| LYNK Professional 430411DS | 10.2–10.3 × 16.5 × 1.5 | Steel, epoxy finish | Drawers 10½ in wide or more |
| LYNK Professional 4304142PK expandable | 13.3–26.5 × 16.5 × 1.5 | Steel, epoxy finish | Wide drawers, large collections |
| Rev-A-Shelf 4SDI-18 | 16 × 19.75 × 1-9/16 | Maple, clear coat | A fitted, furniture-style look |
Our spice drawer guide walks through measuring clear height and choosing an order for your jars. Do that first; it decides whether you need a tray at all.
YouCopia SpiceLiner Spice Drawer Liner
Listed: 10-foot roll, 2.5 inches wide · NBR foam · cut with scissors · measuring tape included · Gray item 50201 (Everything Kitchens)
This is not a tray. It is a roll of soft, non-slip foam that you cut into strips and lay across the drawer, so jars lie in rows without rolling. Because nothing is rigid, it works in a drawer of any width or depth, and jars of different diameters can sit side by side.
Sources disagree on capacity: one retailer lists 20 to 30 jars per drawer (and “20+” elsewhere on the same page), while Crate & Barrel lists 30-plus. The honest answer is that it depends on your jars and drawer. A third-party listing also shows a different item number (50155) for the gray roll, so match the color and length rather than the number alone.
Nothing to fit or trim beyond scissors; jars stay flat, so it suits shallow drawers; it moves with you.
Anyone who wants back rows raised for easier reading. Every jar sits at the same level, so a deep drawer of 40 jars can still feel like a pile.
Retailer specifications · Crate & Barrel listing. ASIN taken from an Amazon URL in a deal listing; confirm the length and color on the page.
iDesign Linus In-Drawer Spice Rack
Listed: 16-5/8 L × 8-1/2 W × 1-1/2 H in, three tiers (Container Store) · 15.54 D × 8.04 W × 1.16 H in, mfr. no. 66220 (Ace Hardware) · plastic
A slim, slanted plastic tray with three tiers, sized for a narrow drawer or for running two side by side in a wider one. The Container Store describes it as Resipreme plastic; Ace notes curved compartments with ridges to hold items in place and suggests it for vitamin bottles as well as spices.
The two retailers list noticeably different dimensions, roughly an inch in length and a third of an inch in height. That may be a different revision or a different way of measuring. If your drawer is tight, buy from a listing whose figures you can match to your measurements.
Narrow width lets you fill a 17-inch drawer with two trays and a gap for packets, or use one in a small drawer.
Anyone with a single wide drawer who wants one piece edge to edge; two trays leave seams and a strip of unused width.
The Container Store listing · Ace Hardware listing. Labeled search link: we could not confirm an ASIN.
LYNK Professional 4-Tier Spice Rack Drawer Organizer, 430411DS
Listed: 10.2–10.3 W × 16.5 D × 1.5 H in · heavy-gauge steel, silver epoxy finish · four tiers · up to 24 standard jars · fits drawers 10-1/2 in wide or more
A fixed-width steel tray with four angled tiers. Home Depot’s listing gives 10.3 inches in the highlights and 10.2 in the spec table. In the listing’s Q&A, LYNK says the drawer should be about 3.25 inches tall for standard spice bottles, that bottles 2 to 2.5 inches wide make the best use of each row, and that the tray is not meant to be trimmed.
Steel won’t warp or splinter, and four tiers give back rows a better view than a flat liner.
Anyone with a drawer under 10½ inches wide or under about 16½ inches deep, since it can’t be cut down. Short drawers under roughly 3¼ inches of clear height may catch taller jars.
Home Depot specifications and LYNK Q&A. ASIN taken from an Amazon URL on a third-party product page for the 10¼-inch tray; confirm the model and width before buying.
LYNK Professional Expandable 4-Tier Spice Rack, 4304142PK
Listed: 13.3–26.5 W × 16.5 D × 1.5 H in · heavy-gauge steel, silver epoxy finish · four tiers · up to 64 standard jars
The expandable version of the tray above. The listing headline gives a 13.3 to 26.5-inch width range, while the spec table lists 13.25 inches, presumably the closed width. In the Q&A, LYNK says it is about 5 pounds empty, cannot be cut to fit, and needs a drawer at least 17 inches deep. Home Depot also lists a separate 14 to 26-inch expandable size, so check which one you’re looking at.
One piece can fill a full-width drawer, with the highest listed capacity here.
Anyone with a drawer narrower than about 13¼ inches or shallower than 17 inches. If you only own 20 jars, it’s more tray than you need.
Home Depot specifications and LYNK Q&A. Labeled search link: we could not confirm an ASIN for this size.
Rev-A-Shelf 4SDI-18 Wood Spice Drawer Insert
Listed: 16 W × 19.75 D × 1-9/16 H in · 100% maple, clear coat · up to three tiers plus one rear compartment · designed for base cabinet drawers 24 in or smaller · trimmable
This is the kind of insert cabinet shops drop into new kitchens. CabinetParts lists it as solid maple with a rear compartment for refills or packets. It can be dropped in as is or trimmed to an exact fit; the listing recommends a table saw for that.
One inconsistency: the description mentions walnut, but the specs say maple, and walnut is sold as a separate listing. Rev-A-Shelf also makes a two-tier “15 Inch Width Trimmable” version, 4SDI-18T-1, listed at 13.23 × 19.49 × 1.95 inches, if your drawer is narrower than 16 inches.
Wood looks at home in a wood kitchen, and trimming lets you close the gaps that fixed trays leave.
Renters and anyone without a table saw (or a helper who has one). At nearly 20 inches deep, it also rules out shallower drawers unless you cut it down.
CabinetParts specifications (4SDI-18) · 4SDI-18T-1 listing. Labeled search link: we could not confirm an ASIN.
Three drawers, three different answers
To see how this plays out, picture three drawers. Your numbers will differ, so measure yours.
- 11 inches wide, 18 deep, 3½ clear: the LYNK 10-inch tray fits the width with a little room to lift it out, and the depth clears its 16.5 inches. The expandable LYNK won’t go in: even closed, it is listed at about 13¼ inches wide.
- 21 inches wide, 20 deep, 3 clear: the expandable LYNK or the Rev-A-Shelf maple insert can fill most of the width. Two iDesign trays side by side would leave roughly 4 inches for a packet bin. With only 3 inches of clear height, lay a tall jar on the top tier and close the drawer before committing.
- 14 inches wide, 15 deep: every tray here is listed deeper than 15 inches, so the liner is the practical choice unless you’re willing to trim wood.
How we chose
This is a research-based comparison from listed specs, not hands-on testing. We have not bought, installed, or used these products. We started with inserts sold by major US retailers and manufacturers, kept ones with clearly stated dimensions, and grouped them by the drawer they suit rather than ranking them against each other.
Specs come from The Container Store, Ace Hardware, Home Depot (including LYNK’s answers in its Q&A), CabinetParts, Everything Kitchens, and Crate & Barrel, checked October 21, 2026. Where listings disagree, we’ve said so above. We didn’t include prices or ratings because they change; check the live listing. See our editorial policy.
- Inside drawer width, measured wall to wall at the narrowest point.
- Inside depth, minus anything at the back like a drawer stop.
- Clear height with the drawer closed, and your tallest jar lying down on the insert’s top tier.
- Jar diameter versus tier depth, so jars don’t hang off the edge.
- Fixed or expandable, and whether the product can be trimmed (the LYNK trays can’t).
- The exact model and size on the listing, since several of these come in more than one width.
Should I buy new jars before or after the insert?
After. Fit the insert to the drawer, then check whether your current jars sit on its tiers. Many people find mismatched jars work fine on a liner or a tiered tray.
Can I use two different inserts in one drawer?
Yes. A narrow tray for everyday spices beside a strip of liner for odd bottles is a common split. Add the widths together and leave a finger’s width to lift each piece out.

Keep reading
More guides for your space
THE KINDRED JOURNAL
Latest from the journal
- Ideal Indoor Humidity in Winter: Find Your Number, Check Your Meter, Then Add Only What the Room NeedsAim for 30 to 50% and never humidify past 50%, let the windows set the limit on the coldest nights, salt-test your hygrometer before you trust it, seal drafts first because a whole bedroom needs only about 4½ ounces of water, and clean the tank on a schedule: a winter humidity guide with the math worked out.
- Toy Storage Ideas: 13 Ways to Make Room Before the Holiday Toy WaveEdit the toys before the gifts arrive, give each kind of play one open bin on an anchored low shelf, keep small parts and spare batteries out of a toddler’s reach, skip latching lids and rotate the extras: thirteen toy storage ideas for the weeks before and after the holidays.
- Best Gift Wrap Organizers: 5 Picks for a Closet Corner, Under the Bed or the Back of a DoorAn upright box that holds up to 32 long rolls, a 41.5-inch under-bed bag for big collections, a water-resistant zip bag, an over-the-door organizer and a slim canvas case for eight rolls: five gift wrap organizers matched to the space you can give them.
- Cord and Cable Storage: 13 Ideas for the Spare Chargers, Cables and Adapters Nobody Can FindMatch every cable to a device you still own, keep a sensible number of spares by connector type, coil them loosely, label the mystery bricks, hang the extension cords and send old batteries and dead cables to a proper drop-off: thirteen ways to store spare cords so the right one turns up in seconds.
- Window Condensation in Winter: Find Which Side the Water Is On, Then Match Humidity to the ForecastDo the wipe test to tell room-side fog from a failed seal, check a hygrometer against the outdoor low, keep humidity at or under 40% above 20°F and 30% below 10°F, run the fans, open the curtains by day and dry wet sills the same morning: a window condensation guide with a worked cold-week example.
- How to Clean a Range Hood Filter Before Holiday Cooking: Know Your Filter Type, Then Put It on the CalendarWash metal mesh and baffle filters in hot soapy water or the dishwasher, replace charcoal filters instead of rinsing them, never run the hood with the filter out, and clean the weekend before Thanksgiving and again before Christmas: a range hood filter guide with a worked holiday cleaning calendar.
- Drying Clothes Indoors in Winter: Where the Rack Goes, How Much Rail You Need and What It SavesOne load gives off about 2 liters of water as it air-dries, so put the rack where that moisture can leave, keep it 3 feet from the space heater, count inches of rail before you buy, space and turn the heavy things, watch humidity and window condensation, and know what the dryer you’re skipping really costs: indoor drying with the math.
- Hat, Glove and Scarf Storage by the Door: One Bin Per Person, Sized to What They Actually WearKeep a daily set plus one dry spare per person, size an open bin for each from a quick measurement, dry wet mittens before they go in, clip pairs together, hang woven scarves and fold knits, skip long scarves on the playground and wash wool before it’s sealed away: a hat and glove station with a worked bin-size example.
- Guest Room That Doubles as Storage: Pick the Bed by Floor Space, Keep the Window ClearCount the nights the room really hosts, compare bed footprints before comfort, put storage on one wall behind a curtain, keep the window and door clear, leave guests half the closet and one drawer, and pack a single guest bin: a storage room that turns into a guest room in fifteen minutes, with a worked 10 by 11 foot example.








