10 Thermostat Mistakes That Cost Homeowners Money

Heating and cooling usually make up the biggest share of a home’s energy use, and one small box on the wall controls all of it. Most people set it once and forget it, or fiddle with it in ways that don’t help. Here are ten mistakes we see most often, and what to do instead.

By Avery Linden · Updated October 2026 · Save on Bills

Smart thermostat on a wall showing the temperature
One small box controls the biggest part of most energy bills. Photograph by Dan LeFebvre / Unsplash.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Shopping links in this post open Amazon search results for a type of item, not a specific product we’ve tested.

1. Turning it way up to heat the house faster

Most furnaces and air conditioners run at one speed. Setting 80°F instead of 70°F doesn’t warm the house faster; it just keeps the system running longer, past the temperature you actually wanted. Set the number you want and wait.

2. Never changing the temperature

The Department of Energy notes you can save on heating and cooling by turning the thermostat back several degrees for about eight hours a day, such as while you’re asleep or at work. A steady 72°F around the clock means paying full price for hours nobody notices.

3. Buying a programmable thermostat and never programming it

A programmable thermostat on “hold” is just an expensive manual thermostat. Spend ten minutes setting a weekday and weekend schedule. If that feels like too much, a smart thermostat that learns your routine may be a better fit. Smart thermostats on Amazon ↗

4. Putting the thermostat in the wrong spot

A thermostat in direct sun, above a lamp or TV, near a kitchen, or next to a drafty door reads the wrong temperature and runs the system at the wrong times. It works best on an interior wall, away from heat sources and drafts. Moving it is a job for an electrician or HVAC tech, but they can tell you quickly whether it’s worth it.

5. Big setbacks with a heat pump

If you have a heat pump, very large overnight setbacks can backfire. When the system tries to recover quickly, it may switch on electric backup heat, which costs much more to run. Use smaller setbacks, or a thermostat designed for heat pumps that limits backup heat. Ask your HVAC installer how your system is set up.

6. Running the fan “On” instead of “Auto”

On “On,” the blower runs all the time, even when the system isn’t heating or cooling. That uses electricity and, in summer, can pull moisture back into the house. “Auto” runs the fan only when it’s needed, which suits most homes.

7. Closing vents in unused rooms

It sounds logical, but in many forced-air systems, closing too many vents raises pressure in the ducts, which can push air out of leaks and make the system work harder. Close a vent or two if a room is too warm, but don’t close half the house.

8. Ignoring the filter

A dirty filter makes your system push air through dust, so it runs longer for the same comfort. Check it monthly in heavy-use seasons. Write the filter size on the furnace so you always buy the right one. HVAC filters on Amazon ↗

9. Fighting the thermostat with space heaters

If one room is always cold, a space heater feels like the fix, but it can trick a nearby thermostat into thinking the house is warm while the rest of it gets cold. Find out why the room is cold first: a blocked vent, a draft, or missing insulation. Our guide to where your home loses heat can help.

Ceiling fan in a bright, empty room with a window
Fans move air, not temperature, so they help only while someone is in the room. Photograph by Bailey Alexander / Unsplash.

10. Forgetting about ceiling fans

Fans don’t change the temperature, but they change how it feels. In summer, a fan blowing down lets you set the thermostat a little higher. In winter, running it slowly in reverse (usually clockwise) pushes warm air from the ceiling back down. Turn fans off when you leave the room, since they cool people, not rooms.

Quick setup for this winter: pick a comfortable daytime temperature, set it a few degrees lower overnight and while you’re out, put the fan on “Auto,” and change the filter. That covers most of the savings in about fifteen minutes.

More ways to stay warm for less are in 13 cheap ways to keep your house warmer this winter.

Common questions

What temperature should I set in winter?

The Department of Energy suggests about 68°F while you’re awake and lower while you’re asleep or away, as long as everyone in the home is comfortable and healthy. Older adults, babies, and anyone with certain health conditions may need a warmer setting.

Is it cheaper to leave the heat on all day?

For most furnaces, no. Your home loses heat more slowly when it’s cooler inside, so turning the temperature back for several hours usually saves energy, even counting the warm-up. Heat pumps are the exception to watch: avoid large setbacks that trigger expensive backup heat.

Smart or programmable thermostat?

Both can save the same amount if you actually use the schedule. A programmable model is cheaper and works fine for a predictable routine. A smart model adjusts itself, can be controlled from your phone, and is easier for people who never set schedules. Check your utility for rebates on either.

Can I install a new thermostat myself?

Many people do, but check compatibility with your system first, especially for heat pumps, older systems, and line-voltage baseboard heaters. Turn off power at the breaker, take a photo of the wiring, and call an HVAC technician if anything doesn’t match the instructions.

Related: 8 signs your furnace or AC is about to fail

10 thermostat mistakes that cost homeowners money
Save this list to your Pinterest board.

Keep reading

More ways to save at home

THE KINDRED JOURNAL

Latest from the journal