Craft Supply Storage Ideas: 13 Ways to Sort Yarn, Paper and Paint So Holiday Projects Start Fast

The most common craft-storage mistake is buying the organizer first. A wall of matching drawers looks great on day one, then the cardstock doesn’t fit, the yarn gets crushed and the hot glue gun ends up back on the counter. Craft supplies come in wildly different shapes, so the storage has to follow the supplies, not the other way around. With holiday cards, ornaments and gift tags coming up, here are thirteen ideas to get your supplies sorted so a project takes ten minutes to set up, not an hour to dig out.

By Avery Linden · Updated November 2026 · Workspace & Garage

Colored pencils in a metal cup beside clear containers of paper shapes
Photograph by Jorge Franganillo / Unsplash.
The short version

Pull everything into one spot, sort it into what you actually make, and only then measure for storage. Paper lies flat or stands upright in a file, yarn goes in something that breathes, messy supplies get lids, and anything small enough to swallow lives above toddler reach. Keep a separate “this season” bin so holiday projects aren’t scattered across the house.

Sort before you store

1. Gather it all, then sort by project, not by material

Craft supplies tend to live in five places at once: a drawer of ribbon, a closet shelf of paper, a bag of yarn under the bed. Bring it all to one table first. Then sort by what you make, such as cards, knitting, kids’ crafts, sewing, rather than by type. A card-making bin with its own scissors, glue and stamps is far quicker to use than a “scissors drawer” across the room.

Try it if you keep buying duplicates of tape or glue because you can’t find the ones you have.

2. Edit with one honest question

For each item, ask: will I use this in the next year? Dried-out markers, glue that’s turned thick or stringy, and a half-finished project you no longer like can go. Donate usable leftovers; schools, libraries and senior centers often take craft supplies, but call first to ask what they need.

3. Measure your biggest flat item before buying anything

Scrapbook paper is typically 12 by 12 inches, and standard letter-size cardstock is 8½ by 11. Those two numbers decide most of your storage: a drawer or bin needs a little more than that inside, not outside, or the edges curl and bend. Check the interior dimensions on any organizer, and measure the shelf or closet it’s going into. Every space is different, so measure yours.

Paper, fabric and yarn

4. Stand paper upright in a file box or magazine holder

Stacked paper gets heavy, and the sheet you want is always at the bottom. Standing it upright in a file box, a 12 x 12 paper holder or sturdy magazine holders lets you flip through by color like files. Keep heavier cardstock in its own holder so it doesn’t slump.

Skip it if the paper is thin tissue or vellum; those crease standing up and do better flat in a shallow drawer.

5. Fold fabric to one size, like a shop

Fabric stores fold bolts and cuts to the same width so they line up. Do the same at home: fold each piece around a ruler or a stiff piece of cardboard to one width, then stand them in a bin or on a shelf so every color shows. Small scraps go in a single bag labeled by size.

6. Give yarn a basket or a bin with air

Yarn holds its shape better when it isn’t squashed, and a woven basket or a bin with some air flow keeps it from feeling musty. If you store wool long term, keep it clean and sealed away from clothes moths, the same way you’d store seasonal sweaters. Keep the label with each skein (a rubber band works) so you can match the dye lot later.

A basket holding balls of white and gray yarn
An open basket keeps the yarn in use visible and uncrushed. Photograph by Kelly Sikkema / Unsplash.

7. Ribbon and washi tape on a rod or dowel

Spools roll and unwind in a drawer. Slide them onto a tension rod in a cabinet, a dowel set across a bin, or a paper towel holder, and pull off what you need. Our gift wrap storage ideas cover the same trick for the wrapping station.

Tools, paint and the messy stuff

8. Stand brushes, pens and markers in cups

Store brushes bristle-up once they’re fully dry, so the tips keep their shape. Markers often last longer stored flat or tip-down depending on the type, so check the package. A row of jars or a spinning caddy on the table keeps the daily colors in reach.

Assorted paintbrushes standing bristle-up in a container
Dry brushes stored bristle-up hold their shape. Photograph by Tasha Kostyuk / Unsplash.

9. Lidded bins for glitter, glue and paint

Anything that spills, sheds or dries out gets a lid. One bin for glitter and sequins, one for glue and adhesives, one for craft paint. Follow each product’s label for storage temperature, and keep them out of a garage that freezes or bakes. Our guide to storing leftover paint explains why temperature matters for paint in general.

10. A tackle box or bead organizer for the tiny pieces

Buttons, beads, brads and charms belong in a divided case with latching lids, one compartment per type. Turn it upside down in the store, or shake it gently at home, to make sure the dividers reach the lid; if they don’t, the pieces mix the first time you tip it.

Small parts and little kids: The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission says toys for children under 3 can’t contain parts small enough to fit in its test cylinder, which is about 1¼ inches wide by 2¼ inches long, roughly the size of a young child’s throat. Most beads, buttons, googly eyes and pom-poms are smaller than that. Keep them in latched cases on a high shelf, and clean the table once older kids finish a project.

Where it all lives

11. Use a closet or a cabinet you can close

Craft supplies are visually busy. A closet with a few adjustable shelves, a rolling cart that tucks into a corner, or a tall cabinet you can shut keeps the room calm. Put the heaviest bins on the lowest shelf, and anchor any tall cabinet or bookcase to the wall, especially in a home with children. Our small home office storage guide has more on fitting supplies around a desk.

Try it if your craft space doubles as a guest room or home office.

12. Label every bin, on the end you see

Opaque bins look tidier but hide what’s inside. Label the end that faces you, not the lid, so you can read it on the shelf. A label maker makes this fast; see our label maker comparison. Picture labels help kids put things back.

13. Pack a “this season” project bin

Between now and New Year’s, put everything for holiday projects into one bin: cardstock for cards, ornament blanks, gift tags, the glue gun and its sticks, ribbon offcuts. Pull it out, make the thing, put the lid back on. When January comes, sort what’s left into your main bins and pack the bin away with the decorations.

A table covered with holiday craft supplies
A single seasonal bin keeps holiday supplies from spreading. Photograph by Julia Taubitz / Unsplash.
SupplyStore itWatch out for
Scrapbook paper, cardstockUpright in a file box or holder sized for 12 x 12 or letter sizeBent corners in containers that are too small
Tissue, vellumFlat in a shallow drawerCreasing when stood up
YarnBasket or bin with some airMoths in long-stored wool; crushed skeins
FabricFolded to one width, standing in a binSun fading on open shelves
Glitter, glue, paintLidded bins, one per typeHeat and freezing; follow the label
Beads, buttonsLatching divided case, up highChoking hazard for children under 3
One-afternoon craft reset
  • Everything gathered to one table.
  • Sorted by project, not by material.
  • Dried-out and unwanted supplies removed.
  • Biggest flat item measured before buying storage.
  • Small parts in latched cases above toddler reach.
  • Bins labeled on the end that faces out.
  • One holiday project bin packed.

Storage to compare

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. These are Amazon searches for the types of storage in this guide, not recommendations for a specific model. Check interior dimensions before you buy.

If the overflow is in a kitchen drawer rather than a craft closet, our junk drawer guide covers the scissors-and-tape problem from the other side.

Questions

What’s the best way to store craft supplies in a small space?

A rolling cart or a few lidded bins in a closet. Sort by project so you only pull out one bin at a time, and use the back of a closet door for flat items like stencils.

Clear bins or opaque bins?

Clear bins help when you need to see colors at a glance; opaque bins look calmer on open shelves. Either way, a label on the front saves opening every lid.

Should yarn go in sealed bins?

For yarn you’re using, an open basket is fine. For long-term storage, especially wool, clean, sealed containers help keep moths out.

Sources: U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Small Parts: What Parents Need to Know. General guidance; follow the storage directions on each product’s label.

13 craft supply storage ideas so holiday projects start fast
Save these ideas to your Pinterest board.

Keep reading

More guides for your space

THE KINDRED JOURNAL

Latest from the journal